News Release April 13, 2023
Yesterday, my lawyers delivered a Libel Notice to Sam Cooper and Global News under the Libel and Slander Act about a false and defamatory March 10, 2023 article titled “Ontario legislature member is part of alleged Beijing 2019 election-interference network: sources”.
The article falsely accuses me of conduct deliberately harmful to Canadian democracy and national security. The defamatory words have exposed me to a campaign of hateful and racist threats and attacks and have significantly tarnished my reputation.
My lawyers have twice asked Mr.Cooper and Global to explain what steps they took to verify the information they published about me. They have refused to provide me with any details.
I have asked that Mr.Cooper and Global publish a retraction and apology by Monday, April 17, 2023.
A copy of the Libel Notice delivered yesterday is enclosed.
VINCENT KE, MPP – DON VALLEY NORTH
2175 Sheppard Avenue East, Suite 103
North York, ON M2J 1W8
Constituency Office PH#: 416-494-8778
Email: vke-co@ola.org
Contact: Christina Liu, Executive Assistant to MPP Ke, PH#:416-823-7188
IN THE MATTER OF the Libel and Slander Act, R.S.O.1990, c.L.12;
AND IN THE MATTER OF an intended action;
BETWEEN:
WENBIN KE
Plaintiff
– and –
SAM COOPER and GLOBAL NEWS (CORUS ENTERTAINMENT)
Defendants
LIBEL NOTICE
TAKE NOTICE that under the Libel and Slander Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.12, the Plaintiff complains of a news article and an accompanying video published by the Defendants Sam Cooper (“Cooper”) and Global News (Corus Entertainment)(“Global”), titled Ontario legislature member is part of alleged Beijing 2019 election-interference network: sources on March 10, 2023, published online at https://globalnews.ca/news9430612/chinese-govemment-canada-election-interference/ (the “Newspaper” and the “Broadcast”), as being libellous and/or slanderous of Wenbin (Vincent) Ke (“Ke”). Copies of a printout of the Newspaper and a screenshot of the Broadcast are attached as Schedule“A”.
THE PLAINTIFF COMPLAINS of the Newspaper and Broadcast as set out above and the following words therein as follows (collectively the “Defamatory Words”):
The Newspaper
An election interference network directed by China’s Toronto consulate allegedly involved a sitting member of the Ontario legislature. according to sources with knowledge of the investigation into Bejing’s covert efforts during the 2019 federal election.
Those sources assert that Vincent Ke, a Progressive Conservative member in Premier Doug Ford’s government since 2018, served as a financial intermediary in Chinese Communist Party (CCP) interference schemes described in two separate Privy Council Office intelligence reports reviewed by Global News.
According to those same sources, Ke received around $50,000 as part of a larger disbursement from the Chinese Consulate in Toronto in the S250000range that was channelled through a series of intermediaries.
[…]
One of the documents that refer to the funding schemes is a January 2022 Privy Council Office (PCO) report, which asserts that the CCP’s Toronto-area network included 11 or more 2019 federal candidates. 13 or more aides and an Ontario MPP.
[…]
The 2022 PCO memo cited in the story maintains that China’s Toronto consulate directed a substantial covert disbursement into a network comprised of at least 11 federal election candidates and numerous Being operatives who worked as their campaign staffers.
“A large clandestine transfer of funds earmarked for the federal election from the PRC Consulate in Toronto was transferred to an elected provincial government official via a staff member of a 2019 federal candidate,” the report states.
It did not mention the official’s name or where they served and did not specify how much money was involved.
Filling in some of the gaps from the memo, sources provided more details about the alleged scheme for the Global News article: they said the consulate transferred around $250,000 to a pro-Beijing grassroots group, and these funds went to the staff member in question.
[…]
Several sources, including a senior intelligence official with a detailed awareness of these CSIS investigations, said Ke is the provincial official.
[…]
Another PCO document that sources say was provided to the Prime Minister’s Office four months after the 2019 federal election advanced similar intelligence about the financing. “Community leaders facilitate the clandestine transfer of funds and recruit potential targets,” the 2020 memo asserted without identifying any recipients.
In the covert funding scheme, those same sources allege, the consulate disbursed around $250,000 through a Toronto-based businessman, Wei Chengyi — and a pro-Beijing community group called the Confederation of Toronto Chinese-Canadian Organizations — through an aide to a federal candidate running for the 2019 contest. In turn, the aide allegedly provided about $50.000 of that sum to Ke.
[…]
The alleged transactions renew questions among some national security experts about loopholes in the Canadian electoral system that permit sophisticated interference networks from countries such as China, Iran and Russia to influence outcomes.
The Broadcast:
Vincent Ke became the first immigrant from mainland China to be elected Ontario Conservative MPP … but intelligence sources say the MPP was also a part of an alleged foreign interference network to advance Being’s political agenda.
During the 2019 federal election campaign, sources say the Chinese Consulate transferred around $250,000 through a network that involved at least 11 federal election candidates, campaign staffers and other politicians both Liberal and Conservative, including Liberal MP Han Dong, who has denied the allegations. The funds were allegedly sent first through a businessman, Wei Chengyi, then sources say the money flowed to a federal candidate staff member and to Ke, who received about $50,000.
The allegations stem from interviews with Canadian intelligence sources, including a senior official with a detailed awareness of the CSIS investigations
THE PLAINTIFF STATES that the foregoing Defamatory Words in the Newspaper and Broadcast are libellous and/or slanderous of Ke in the way of his reputation and occupation, accuse him of conduct and association deliberately harmful to Canadian democracy and national security, interfere with and injure his political career, including his relationships with his constituents, fellow politicians, Canadian and western democratic institutions, structures and traditions and Canadian citizens at large. The Defamatory Words have exposed Ke to a campaign of hateful and racist threats and attacks, including harassing and threatening voicemails and messages left on his office phone and social media pages/inboxes by members of the public.
THE DEFAMATORY WORDS ARE MEANT AND UNDERSTOOD TO MEAN that
the Plaintiff:
- Is engaged in, gives material support to and is operative in service of an election interference scheme directed by the government of China.
- Has been identified by the national security apparatus as a threat to national security as a member of a Chinese government election interference scheme.
- Received and distributed funds in the service of the government of China as part of an election interference scheme.
- Is a conduit for illegal or illicit foreign funds.
- Participated in China’s scheme to subvert the democratic process and Canadian democracy and interfere with the 2019 federal election.
- Is not loyal to, is a foreign agent and works to subvert and undermine the best interest of, his constituents, Canadian citizens or Canada.
- Conducts his political carrier for nefarious and/or unlawful purposes that are a threat to Canadian democracy and national security.
- Cannot properly fulfill his duties as an MPP.
- Is unsuitable to represent the interests of Canadian citizens as an MPP or a politician.
- Puts the interests of the Chinese government over that of Canada.
- Promotes interests of the Chinese government to the detriment of Canada and Canadian citizens, democracy and the rule of law.
- Is a threat to Canadian democracy.
- Is a threat to the national security of Canada.
- Is a threat to Canadian citizens.
- Is a dishonest person.
- Is not a person of high moral character.
THE DEFENDANTS Cooper and Global published and broadcasted the Newspaper and the Broadcast containing the aforementioned Defamatory Words and stated the aforementioned Defamatory Words.
THE DEFENDANTS Cooper and Global were motivated by malice when they published, broadcasted and stated the Defamatory Words. Their conduct was high-handed and callous and demonstrated a total disregard for the truth of the Plaintiff’s reputation and occupation.
THE DEFENDANTS Cooper and Global knew that the information they received and published was not reliable, took no steps to verify its accuracy and broadcasted the information deliberately or recklessly with knowledge that it would injure Vincent Ke.
THE PLAINTIFF demands that Cooper and Global immediately: (1) remove and/or destroy copies of the Newspaper and Broadcast and any reference to the Defamatory Words from any source or place accessible to any person other than the Defendants; (2)publish an unequivocal apology and retraction of the Defamatory Words in a written letter to be posted in prominent locations and on all platforms used by the Defendants, including Global’s website and the Defendants’ social media platforms (the “Apology Letter”); and (3) post online a video of Cooper and a Global executive reading out loud the Apology Letter in prominent locations and on all platforms used by the Defendants, including Global’s website and the Defendants’ social media platforms, by the conclusion of business day on Monday, April 17, 2023. Failure to do so will result in a legal proceeding being commenced against the Defendants.
THE PLAINTIFF requires the Defendants to maintain all records, drafts, notes, communications and website activities referable to the Newspaper, the Broadcast or the Defamatory Words, including but not limited to all original and unedited footage of the Broadcastall drafts of the Newspaper, any script for the Broadcast, and the Defamatory Words, all inteinternalmunications between the Defendants and any third party relating to the Broadcast, the Newspaper or the Defamatory Words, and all emails, correspondence and comments received from viewers in response to or commenting on the Broadcast, the Newspaper or the Defamatory Words.
THE PLAINTIFF requires the Defendants to identify and provide the particulars on any steps taken to validate the reliability of the information published and broadcasted in the Newspaper and Broadcast, including but not limited to the following information requested in the letter from the Plaintiffs’ counsel to the Defendants sent March 28, 2023:
- The steps the Defendants took to verify the reliability of their sources and the information the sources provided to them, including requests, if any, of intelligence officials for confirmation;
- The steps the Defendants took to determine whether the information reported in the Newspaper and Broadcast was reviewed by the sources’ superiors for inclusion in official reports and government briefings;
- The number of sources that corroborated the statements made about Ke;
- The efforts the Defendants made with intelligence officials beyond the sources including CSIS and the PCO, to verify and corroborate the information reported and any responses received in response to the efforts;
- How the Defendants communicated with their anonymous sources (e.g., email, text, phone, etc.); and
- Whether the Defendants have kept records of their investigation and if so, in what format.
AND TAKE NOTICE that this Notice is provided to you under the provisions of the Libel and Slander Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. L.12.
THE PLAINTIFF hereby gives notice that Plaintiff will seek damages, interest and costs in the proceeding that they will commence.
THE PLAINTIFF hereby gives notice under the Courts of Justice Act that they will be claiming pre-judgment interest from the date of this Notice to the date of Judgment.
DATED at Toronto this 12th day of April, 2023:
LAX O’SULLIVAN LISUS GOTTLIEB LLP
Counsel
Suite 2750, 145 King Street West
Toronto ON M5H 1J8
Jonathan C. Lisus LSO#:32952H
jlisusl@lolg.ca
Tel: 416 598 7873
Niklas Holmberg LSO#:63696G
nholmberg@lolg.ca
Tel: 416 645 3787
Xin Lu (Crystal) Li LSO#:766670
cli@lolg.ca
Tel: 416 956 0112
Lawyers for the Plaintiff
TO: ORP LAW
180 Dundas Street West
Suite 1500
Toronto ON M5G 1Z8
Douglas Richardson LSO#:37983R
drichardson@orplawyers.com
Tel: 416 216 0256
Lawyers for the Defendants,
Sam Cooper and Global News (Corus Entertainment)
SCHEDULE”A”
Ontario legislature member is part of alleged Beijing 2019 election-interference network: sources
Sam Cooper
allegedly involved a sitting member of the Ontario legislature, according to sources with knowledge of the investigation into Beijing’s covert efforts during the 2019 federal election.
Those sources assert that Vincent Ke, a Progressive Conservative member in Premier Doug Ford’s government since 2018, served as a financial intermediary in Chinese Communist Party (CCP) interference schemes described in two separate Privy Council Office intelligence reports reviewed by Global News.
According to those same sources, Ke received around $50,000, part of a larger disbursement from the Chinese Consulate in Toronto in the $250,000 range that was channelled through a series of intermediaries.
Ke has denied the allegations.
One of the documents that refer to the funding schemes is a January 2022 Privy Council Office (PCO) report, which asserts that the CCP’s Toronto-area network included 11 or more 2019 federal candidates, 13 or more aides, and an Ontario MPP.
The report does not mention Ke by name but described in detail how the alleged network operated.
Ontario legislature member is part of alleged Beijing 2019 election-interference network: sources
This high-level, finalized document was produced by the Intelligence Assessment Secretariat — a division of the PCO that regularly provides national security alerts for Canada’s Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his cabinet.
Prime Minister’s Office spokeswoman Alison Murphy gave a blanket denial Tuesday that Justin Trudeau was aware of Beijing’s money transfers to the 2019 candidates.
“As the Prime Minister stated last fall, we have no information on any federal candidates receiving money from China,” Murphy wrote in a statement.
The response refers to Global’s reporting last November, which did not state that China gave money directly to candidates. Instead, the story described through documents and intelligence sources how the consulate in Toronto allegedly orchestrated funding through local proxies to fund network members.
The 2022 PCO memo cited in the story maintains that China’s Toronto consulate directed a substantial, covert disbursement into a network comprised of at least 11 federal election candidates and numerous Beijing operatives who worked as their campaign staffers.
“A large clandestine transfer of funds earmarked for the federal election from the PRC Consulate in Toronto was transferred to an elected provincial government official via a staff member of a 2019 federal candidate,” the report states.
It did not mention the official’s name or where they served and did not specify how much money was involved.
Filling in some of the gaps from the memo, sources provided more details about the alleged scheme for the Global News article: they said the consulate transferred around $250,000 to a pro-Beijing grassroots group, and these funds went to the staff member in question.
in general terms, sources said, CSIS uses intelligence shared from Western allies, human source reporting, electronic interceptions, and Canadian financial intelligence documents to reveal information on transfers from Chinese consular officials into the Canadian political system.
Global News granted its intelligence sources anonymity, which they requested because they risk prosecution under the Security of Information Act.
Several sources, including a senior intelligence official with a detailed awareness of these CSIS investigations, said Ke is the provincial official.
Ke represents the Ontario riding of Don Valley North, a diverse riding where many people of Chinese origin live.
Another PCO document that sources say was provided to the Prime Minister’s Office four months after the 2019 federal election advanced similar intelligence about the financing. “Community leaders facilitate the clandestine transfer of funds and recruit potential targets,” the2020 memo asserted, without identifying any recipients.
In the covert funding scheme, those same sources allege, the consulate disbursed around $250,000 through a Toronto-based businessman, Wei Chengyi — and a pro-Beijing community group called the Confederation of Toronto Chinese-Canadian Organizations — throuah an aide to a federal candidate running for the 2019 contest. In turn, the aide allegedly provided about $50,000 of that sum to Ke.
Wei and Ke deny playing any role in the alleged network or receiving direct or indirect funding from the consulate.
Vincent Ke’s lawyer, Gavin Tighe, said that the allegations Global News has collected from national security documents and sources are “patently and maliciously false.”
Tighe has previously represented Doug Ford.
Premier Ford has previously defended Ke.
Wei has previously denied being a middleman in the alleged scheme. “Not only is it not true, but it is also a complete fabrication,” he said in a statement following the Global News report in November.
No charges have been laid, and the transactions could be considered legal under Canada’s current laws.
Facing growing concern over reports of foreign interference, Justin Trudeau announced on Monday that two investigations into Chinese interference would be reviewed by a special rapporteur and that the Public Safety Minister, Marco Mendocino, will take further steps toward establishing a foreign agents’ registry.
Vincent Ke broke ground for Premier Ford in 2018 by becoming the Ontario Conservative Party’s first-ever MPP born on China’s mainland.
Freguently cited by party leaders as a strong fundraiser, Ke built his profile as a Toronto community leader before running for office.
A previous media report by the National Post questioned Ke’s 2013 visit to China, where he allegedly attended a week-long training session for diaspora community leaders organized by the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office (OCAO), an organ of the CCP that has since been probed in Canadian national security cases.
In response to the National Post story, Ontario Premier Doug Ford’s press secretary offered support. “MPP Ke is an important part of the Progressive Conservative caucus and represents his constituents with their best interests in mind” Ivana Yelich said.
In 2022 a federal court judge found “there are reasonable grounds to believe that OCAO engaged in espionage against overseas Chinese communities in Canada.”
But Ke said he was unaware of “potential risks” when he attended the OCAO session.
“The 2013 conference took place long before the said 2022 court ruling,” Ke said in response to Global News. “Therefore, along with most Canadians, I was not aware of any potential risks associated with the organizer of the conference.”
Ford’s office said that it could not comment on the allegations and that Canadian police and intelligence agencies have not informed the premier about them.
When approached by a Global News reporter at Queen’s Park for comment about his alleged role in the transfer, Ke said he had nothing to do with election interference.
“This is a false accusation. This is racist,” he said. “It’s racist because l was born in China because I come from China.”
Wei’s organization also disputes that it was involved in the scheme.
In a brief phone call with Global News, a man who identified himself as a CTCCO official described allegations that Wei and CTCCO are involved in a Chinese foreign interference campaign as nonsense.
“No,we are never involved in those allegations,” the unidentified CTCCO official said. “I don’t want to give my name. But don’t use those allegations without evidence.”
Jack Jia, a Chinese-language journalist who has delved into Ke’s previous political activities, says that claims of prejudice can sometimes be used for strategic purposes. “They use racism … to distract the real issue here.”
The January 2022 report and another PCO report from 2020 concluded that some of the 11 or more candidates targeted by Beijing in the 2019 election were witting of CCP influence efforts, and some were not. Global News has reviewed both documents.
Global News could not independently confirm allegations regarding the financial transfers allegedly handled by Wei and Ke. Moreover, its sources did not provide Global with any further details about how — if at all — the alleged recipients used the funds.
A spokesman for CSIS said the service could not comment on details of its investigations.
“As we have previously discussed, CSIS continues to engage with all levels of government to ensure they are aware of the national security threats facing our country, including foreign interference,” spokesman Eric Balsam said. “With regard to your questions, as you might expect, in order to protect Canada and Canadians, CSIS is unable to comment on specific investigations, methodologies, or activities in order to maintain the integrity of its operations.”
The alleged transactions renew questions among some national security experts about loopholes in the Canadian electoral system that permit sophisticated interference networks from countries such as China, Iran and Russia to influence outcomes.
Subtitled “China/Canada: Subtle But Effective Interference Networks in
the Greater Toronto Area,” the February2020 PCO document explains how Chinese election-interference networks allegedly operate through President Xi Jinping’s United Front Work Department, which seeks to influence foreign politicians and government officials into taking specific stances on China’s issues of interest.”
According to CSIS, the United Front Work Department is the CCP’s global-influence arm, a powerfully resourced organ that facilitates espionage and seeks to mobilize Diaspora communities to meddle in foreign states.
The 2020 PCO document, which does not mention Ke or Wei, also explains the centrality of community networks in the United Front’s
strategy: local grassroots groups and allies obscure the CCP’s covert financing of election candidates and insulate Chinese consular officials from hands-on meddling.
“The United Front Work Department’s extensive network of quasi-official and local community and interest groups allow it to obfuscate communication and the flow of funds between Canadian targets and Chinese officials,” the report says. “Under broad guidance from the consulate, co-opted staff of targeted politicians provide advice on
China-related issues, and community leaders facilitate the clandestine transfer of funds and recruit potential targets.”
Bill Blair the former Public Safety Minister, is the only federal official to acknowledge the 2020 PCO briefing — which concluded Xi’s United Front election interference was likely to increase in future elections.
Now Emergency Preparedness Minister, Blair declined to elaborate on its allegations. “I’m aware of that memo andreceived certain information of it” Blair said. “I’m not able to share the details of that.”
A 2017 draft memo, intended for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his office more than a year before the 2019 federal election, made a similar allegation, stating that Chinese agents were “assisting Canadian candidates running for political offices.”
The memo did not identify any individuals suspected to be involved in the alleged interference.
It also alleged that to avoid detection, Chinese officials used local, pro-Beijing community groups as intermediaries to engage Canadian politicians they identified as strategically valuable.
This is the first time that allegations of involvement with the 2019 foreign interference network have pointed to a sitting provincial official with a Conservative background.
Global News reported last month that three weeks before the 2019 election, national security officials allegedly gave an urgent, classified briefing to Liberal Party officials, warning them that one of their candidates, Han Dong, was part of the 2019 Chinese foreign interference network.
A former Ontario MPP, Dong is now Don Valley North MP. He has denied allegations that he was one of the eleven or more candidates who participated in the supposed network. “l am unaware of the claims provided to you by alleged sources, which contains seriously inaccurate information,” he said in a statement to Global News.
Trudeau publicly supported Dong, and his senior ministers have maintained that the overall integrity of the 2019 and 2021 elections remained intact.
While federal Tories assail the Liberals for not addressing issues of foreign interference, they themselves have appeared reluctant to address possible interference publicly among their own ranks, whether as potential participants or targets.
Several Conservative sources have spoken off the record to Global News and said they were indeed targeted, while former federal leader Erin O’Toole said in August, that the party may have lost as many as nine seats in the 2021 election due to Chinese foreign interference. To date, however, former MP Kenny Chiu is the only alleged target to have spoken publicly about his own experience.
Global News asked the CPC why several former B.C. and Ontario candidates whom intelligence sources say were targeted in the 2021 election have not stepped forward to share their concerns.
“To the contrary, Michael Chong is the Conservative Shadow Minister for Foreign Affairs and has been very outspoken on this issue,” wrote party spokesman Sebastian Skamski in an email. “I would note that the others you mention are no longer MPs and are private citizens who are of course free to speak out as they like — as all Canadians are.”
— with files from Jeff Semple and Colin D’Mello
Disclaimer：
Voices & Bridges publishes opinions like this from the community to encourage constructive discussion and debate on important issues. Views represented in the articles are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of the V&B.